Philosodialogue

Center for self propelled discussion, critique and dialogue in philosophy of music education (and related issues...)

Monday, October 16, 2006

Morals and the Status Quo

In Cathy Benedict’s article, she states, “We need to step back and check whether our assumptions about students---differences in their perceptions of discipline and of structure, differences between their sense of order and our own---stem from our particular dominant status quo experience.” I believe that this statement brings up the question of morals. Each of us was raised in a different experience with different morals and modes of proper behavior. These experiences could have to do with our religious beliefs, culture, or location of childhood. People with similar upbringings tend to have different morals in their later years. Benedict states that we must be aware of our students’ different morals and proper behaviors. However, this is extremely difficult. Because 90% of teachers are white, those teachers were raised with similar morals. Therefore, the white middle class moral system is taught in the classroom. I do not believe that teachers are trying to retain the status quo. The issue of schools repeating the dominant power structure could be due to the teachers’ individual morals.

1 Comments:

At 10:25 PM, Blogger Matthew J. LaPine said...

This is a well thought out post, so it deserves a well thought out comment. Although I’m not sure that I can give that sort of insight, I can share my thoughts on the subject.

I think that the changing of morals comes from a changing in life experiences. In my personal life, I have found that my thoughts about other people has changed drastically, even over the past year.

So, this is our job: To always question our practices and to revise them as necessary. That is what I am getting out of this course; I am constantly questioning my practices. Not just my teaching practices, but my life practices. Who I am is constantly changing based on new thoughts and new beliefs.

I sure hope I always continue to do this…

 

Post a Comment

<< Home