Philosodialogue

Center for self propelled discussion, critique and dialogue in philosophy of music education (and related issues...)

Sunday, November 12, 2006

More on Gender Roles

Last Tuesday in Curriculum, Joe Abramo visited class and gave the presentation he gave at the Teacher’s College Conference a few months ago. Joe Abramo’s presentation was a study of gender roles in middle school rock bands. Seeing the presentation a second time caused continued thought on the role of gender in the music classroom. The music classroom is one of the only classrooms where gender distinctions are prominent. In the choir we separate the students by gender and are constantly looking for boys to sing in the choir. There is no other subject in school, with possibly the exception of drama, where the teacher is often looking for boys to be in their class. How do the girls feel about being the majority in the class? Does it make them feel expendable? How do boys feel about always been recruited in a subject that is considered “girly”? I’ve realized, after the presentation, that gender issues are such prominent issues in the music class that they have to be addressed.

1 Comments:

At 10:45 AM, Blogger jodi m said...

This is such an interesting topic. Another important question is, why is chorus considered "girly," or is it? I have many boys in my 6th grade choir who would disagree that chorus is "girly."

In my experience, I often feel jealous of men because there are far fewer of them pursuing a professional career as classical vocalists. Although having a professional career in voice is challenging for everyone, in my experience it seems to be even moreso for women because there are just so many more women who pursue this type of career. In our popular culture, is it more "acceptable" for men to pursue rock, rap, or R&B careers than to pursue a classical career? Is a classical career more "girly" or is it just unpopular?

 

Post a Comment

<< Home